profile

The Signal by Good Signals

Google survives antitrust trial… but has anything actually changed?

Published 3 months ago • 2 min read

​

Google survives antitrust trial… but has anything actually changed?

The biggest tech monopoly trial in decades has just wrapped up. A U.S. court ruled last year that Google had violated antitrust law by illegally maintaining its dominance in search. Yesterday, the judge finally handed down the remedies. And the question is: Google survives the trial… but has anything actually changed?
​
On paper, yes. Google is banned from making billion-dollar exclusive search deals - like paying Apple to be the preset option. It must also share parts of its search index and user interaction data with rivals. That’s an attempt to give Bing, DuckDuckGo - even AI players like ChatGPT and Perplexity - a fighting chance.
​
But the big penalties didn’t happen. Google keeps Chrome. It keeps Android. It can still pay for distribution - just not on an exclusive basis. And Alphabet’s stock jumped eight percent after the ruling.
​
If this is punishment, why does it look like reward?
​
Part of the answer lies in the judge’s caution. He argued that forcing Google to sell off parts or banning payments outright would “jolt the system” and even “cripple” distribution partners like Apple or Samsung who rely on Google’s money.
​
Meanwhile, Google pointed to AI rivals like OpenAI and Perplexity as proof it’s no longer a monopoly - even though Cloudflare’s data shows it still commands nearly 90% of global search.

For now, the only change is small cracks opening - but the empire remains. Google also plans to appeal, which means real change could take years.

The trial may be over, but the fight for the future of search - and who controls the gateway to the internet - is just beginning.

For marketers, the message is simple: Google is still the gatekeeper. For now, keep focusing there - that’s where the traffic is. But watch the cracks. If rivals wedge their way in, the search landscape could shift in ways we’ve never seen.
​
And while next month’s ads trial will dominate headlines, for organic marketers this ruling is the one that matters.
​
​

More on this story from around the web:

​
Best coverage:
​
• Google avoids break-up but must share data with rivals by Lily Jamali on BBC News
​
• US v. Google: all the news from the search antitrust showdown by staff on The Verge
​
• Google avoids break up, but has to give up exclusive search deals in antitrust trial by Rebecca Bellan on TechCrunch
​
• Google won't be broken up in monopoly case but required to share search data by Barry Schwartz on Search Engine Roundtable
​
Public statements:
​
• Read our statement on today’s decision in the case involving Google Search by Lee-Anne Mulholland on Google
​
• Statement by DuckDuckGo by DuckDuckGo on X
​
US v Google: 230-page Remedies ruling PDF:
​
​Judge Amit Mehta’s 230-page remedies ruling in the U.S. v. Google antitrust case (warning: 230 pages long)​
​
​

​
​Watch: Voice translation live demo on #Pixel10​
​
Made By Google YouTube Channel
​
Google showed off Pixel 10’s Voice Translate with Jimmy Fallon - live calls flipping English ↔ Spanish in each person’s own voice, all on-device for privacy.
​
​​
Shared on X​
​
Despite the “SEO is dead” chatter, Charly Wargnier spotted that OpenAI is hiring a content and SEO specialist - with a salary of up to $400K.
​

Michael Chidzey, Editor of The Signal​
​
The web’s noisy. The Signal cuts through it.
​
I built my first website in ’98. And I never stopped. Growth became the craft. Craft became Good Signals.
​
At Good Signals, we help brands that deserve to do better online - do just that. From scaling startups and e-commerce stores, to managing complex websites and guiding billion-pound organisations, the mission’s always been the same: build growth that lasts, and makes business - and the web - better.

Last thing.

We hope you enjoy this email from Good Signals. However, if you no longer wish to receive any further communications from us, you can simply unsubscribe below.

Good Signals, Studio 1, The Bottle Factory, 12 Ossory Road, London, Greater London SE1 5AN
​
​P.S. You can update your preferences here.

The Signal by Good Signals

Your weekly guide to online marketing, technology, and the future of the internet.

Your website is like a dog. That dog needs love, care and attention. Go on, sign up to The Signal and discover how to whip up some Scooby Snacks for your prize pooch.

Read more from The Signal by Good Signals

Google is Putting Gemini 3 in Front of 2 Billion Users This week, Google integrated Gemini 3 directly into Search. It's live now in AI Mode, with changes to AI Overviews rolling out over the next few weeks.Here is the official announcement: Google: A new era of intelligence with Gemini 3 What's changing:Dynamic Interfaces: Your users' queries will trigger instant comparison tables, calculators, interactive simulations, magazine-style layouts directly in Google - all generated on the fly...

4 days ago • 5 min read

What do we do about ChatGPT, Perplexity, and AI agents? Last week, I presented at BrightonSEO - the world's largest search marketing conference - where thousands of marketers and business leaders gathered to discuss what's actually working in digital marketing right now. My session: The Agentic Era: How to Optimise for AI Agents, Not Just Humans [access slides here]. As you'd expect, AI dominated most conversations. But here's what surprised me: Nobody was panicking. Instead, conversations...

26 days ago • 4 min read

Everything wrong with optimising for ChatGPT, Claude, AI Mode, Perplexity, AI Overviews… It's occurred to me over the last year that we've talked endlessly about AI - new models and rollouts, updates, features, growth numbers, even the personalities - but we've barely touched on the one question that keeps coming up behind the scenes: "How do you rank higher on LLMs?"ChatGPT? AI Mode? Perplexity? Claude? Should each be optimised differently?These are fair questions.But here's the thing: they...

about 2 months ago • 4 min read